fixed some incrdecr optimization issues

This commit is contained in:
Irmen de Jong 2018-02-21 00:50:09 +01:00
parent 920b6ca51e
commit e41efef204
8 changed files with 176 additions and 114 deletions

View File

@ -21,7 +21,8 @@ def generate_assignment(ctx: Context) -> None:
def generate_aug_assignment(ctx: Context) -> None:
# for instance: value += 3 (value = 0-255 for now)
# for instance: value += 33
# (note that with += and -=, values 0..255 usually occur as the more efficient incrdecr statements instead)
# left: Register, SymbolName, or Dereference. right: Expression/LiteralValue
out = ctx.out
stmt = ctx.stmt
@ -36,7 +37,7 @@ def generate_aug_assignment(ctx: Context) -> None:
if stmt.operator not in ("<<=", ">>=") or rvalue.value != 0:
_generate_aug_reg_int(out, lvalue, stmt.operator, rvalue.value, "", ctx.scope)
else:
raise CodeError("aug. assignment value must be 0..255", rvalue)
raise CodeError("aug. assignment value must be 0..255", rvalue) # @todo value > 255
else:
raise CodeError("constant integer literal or variable required for now", rvalue) # XXX
elif isinstance(rvalue, SymbolName):
@ -46,7 +47,7 @@ def generate_aug_assignment(ctx: Context) -> None:
if symdef.datatype.isinteger() and 0 <= symdef.value.const_value() <= 255: # type: ignore
_generate_aug_reg_int(out, lvalue, stmt.operator, symdef.value.const_value(), "", ctx.scope) # type: ignore
else:
raise CodeError("aug. assignment value must be integer 0..255", rvalue)
raise CodeError("aug. assignment value must be integer 0..255", rvalue) # @todo value > 255
elif symdef.datatype == DataType.BYTE:
_generate_aug_reg_int(out, lvalue, stmt.operator, 0, symdef.name, ctx.scope)
else:
@ -60,7 +61,7 @@ def generate_aug_assignment(ctx: Context) -> None:
elif isinstance(rvalue, Dereference):
print("warning: {}: using indirect/dereferece is very costly".format(rvalue.sourceref))
if rvalue.datatype != DataType.BYTE:
raise CodeError("aug. assignment value must be a byte, 0..255", rvalue)
raise CodeError("aug. assignment value must be a byte, 0..255", rvalue) # @todo value > 255
if isinstance(rvalue.operand, (LiteralValue, SymbolName)):
if isinstance(rvalue.operand, LiteralValue):
what = to_hex(rvalue.operand.value)

View File

@ -1,14 +1,14 @@
"""
Programming Language for 6502/6510 microprocessors, codename 'Sick'
This is the code generator for the in-place incr and decr instructions.
Incrementing or decrementing variables by a small value 0..255 (for integers)
Incrementing or decrementing variables by a small byte value 0..255
is quite frequent and this generates assembly code tweaked for this case.
Written by Irmen de Jong (irmen@razorvine.net) - license: GNU GPL 3.0
"""
from ..plyparse import VarType, VarDef, Register, IncrDecr, SymbolName, Dereference, LiteralValue, datatype_of
from ..datatypes import DataType, REGISTER_BYTES
from ..plyparse import VarDef, Register, IncrDecr, SymbolName, Dereference, LiteralValue
from ..datatypes import VarType, DataType, REGISTER_BYTES
from . import CodeError, preserving_registers, to_hex, Context, scoped_name
@ -17,10 +17,10 @@ def generate_incrdecr(ctx: Context) -> None:
stmt = ctx.stmt
scope = ctx.scope
assert isinstance(stmt, IncrDecr)
assert isinstance(stmt.howmuch, (int, float)) and stmt.howmuch >= 0
assert stmt.operator in ("++", "--")
if stmt.howmuch == 0:
return
if not 0 <= stmt.howmuch <= 255:
raise CodeError("incr/decr value must be 0..255 - other values should have been converted into an AugAssignment")
target = stmt.target # one of Register/SymbolName/Dereference, or a VarDef
if isinstance(target, SymbolName):
symdef = scope.lookup(target.name)
@ -28,10 +28,6 @@ def generate_incrdecr(ctx: Context) -> None:
target = symdef # type: ignore
else:
raise CodeError("cannot incr/decr this", symdef)
if stmt.howmuch > 255:
if datatype_of(target, scope) != DataType.FLOAT:
raise CodeError("only supports integer incr/decr by up to 255 for now")
howmuch_str = str(stmt.howmuch)
if isinstance(target, Register):

View File

@ -39,7 +39,6 @@ class Optimizer:
self.create_aug_assignments()
self.optimize_assignments()
self.remove_superfluous_assignments()
self.combine_assignments_into_multi()
# @todo optimize addition with self into shift 1 (A+=A -> A<<=1)
self.optimize_goto_compare_with_zero()
self.join_incrdecrs()
@ -48,9 +47,54 @@ class Optimizer:
# @todo analyse for unreachable code and remove that (f.i. code after goto or return that has no label so can never be jumped to)
def join_incrdecrs(self) -> None:
def combine(incrdecrs: List[IncrDecr], scope: Scope) -> None:
# combine the separate incrdecrs
replaced = False
total = 0
for i in incrdecrs:
if i.operator == "++":
total += i.howmuch
else:
total -= i.howmuch
if total == 0:
replaced = True
for x in incrdecrs:
scope.remove_node(x)
else:
is_float = False
if isinstance(target, SymbolName):
symdef = target.my_scope().lookup(target.name)
is_float = isinstance(symdef, VarDef) and symdef.datatype == DataType.FLOAT
elif isinstance(target, Dereference):
is_float = target.datatype == DataType.FLOAT
if is_float or -255 <= total <= 255:
replaced = True
for x in incrdecrs[1:]:
scope.remove_node(x)
incrdecr = self._make_incrdecr(incrdecrs[0], target, abs(total), "++" if total >= 0 else "--")
scope.replace_node(incrdecrs[0], incrdecr)
else:
# total is > or < than 255, make an augmented assignment out of it instead of an incrdecr
aug_assign = AugAssignment(operator="-=" if total < 0 else "+=", sourceref=incrdecrs[0].sourceref) # type: ignore
left = incrdecrs[0].target
right = LiteralValue(value=abs(total), sourceref=incrdecrs[0].sourceref) # type: ignore
left.parent = aug_assign
right.parent = aug_assign
aug_assign.nodes.append(left)
aug_assign.nodes.append(right)
aug_assign.mark_lhs()
replaced = True
for x in incrdecrs[1:]:
scope.remove_node(x)
scope.replace_node(incrdecrs[0], aug_assign)
if replaced:
self.optimizations_performed = True
self.num_warnings += 1
print_warning("{}: merged a sequence of incr/decrs or augmented assignments".format(incrdecrs[0].sourceref))
for scope in self.module.all_nodes(Scope):
incrdecrs = [] # type: List[IncrDecr]
target = None
incrdecrs = [] # type: List[IncrDecr]
for node in list(scope.nodes):
if isinstance(node, IncrDecr):
if target is None:
@ -61,54 +105,17 @@ class Optimizer:
incrdecrs.append(node)
continue
if len(incrdecrs) > 1:
# optimize...
replaced = False
total = 0
for i in incrdecrs:
if i.operator == "++":
total += i.howmuch
else:
total -= i.howmuch
if total == 0:
replaced = True
for x in incrdecrs:
scope.remove_node(x)
else:
is_float = False
if isinstance(target, SymbolName):
symdef = target.my_scope().lookup(target.name)
if isinstance(symdef, VarDef) and symdef.datatype == DataType.FLOAT:
is_float = True
elif isinstance(target, Dereference):
is_float = target.datatype == DataType.FLOAT
if is_float:
replaced = True
for x in incrdecrs[1:]:
scope.remove_node(x)
incrdecr = self._make_incrdecr(incrdecrs[0], target, abs(total), "++" if total >= 0 else "--")
scope.replace_node(incrdecrs[0], incrdecr)
elif 0 < total <= 255:
replaced = True
for x in incrdecrs[1:]:
scope.remove_node(x)
incrdecr = self._make_incrdecr(incrdecrs[0], target, total, "++")
scope.replace_node(incrdecrs[0], incrdecr)
elif -255 <= total < 0:
replaced = True
total = -total
for x in incrdecrs[1:]:
scope.remove_node(x)
incrdecr = self._make_incrdecr(incrdecrs[0], target, total, "--")
scope.replace_node(incrdecrs[0], incrdecr)
if replaced:
self.optimizations_performed = True
self.num_warnings += 1
print_warning("{}: merged a sequence of incr/decrs or augmented assignments".format(incrdecrs[0].sourceref))
combine(incrdecrs, scope) # type: ignore
incrdecrs.clear()
target = None
if isinstance(node, IncrDecr):
incrdecrs.append(node)
target = node.target
# it was an incrdecr with a different target than what we had gathered so far.
if target is None:
target = node.target
incrdecrs.append(node)
if len(incrdecrs) > 1:
# combine remaining incrdecrs at the bottom of the block
combine(incrdecrs, scope) # type: ignore
def _same_target(self, node1: Union[Register, SymbolName, Dereference],
node2: Union[Register, SymbolName, Dereference]) -> bool:
@ -181,7 +188,7 @@ class Optimizer:
def optimize_assignments(self) -> None:
# remove assignment statements that do nothing (A=A)
# remove augmented assignments that have no effect (x+=0, x-=0, x/=1, x//=1, x*=1)
# convert augmented assignments to simple incr/decr if possible (A+=10 => A++ by 10)
# convert augmented assignments to simple incr/decr if value allows it (A+=10 => incr A by 10)
# simplify some calculations (x*=0, x**=0) to simple constant value assignment
# @todo remove or simplify logical aug assigns like A |= 0, A |= true, A |= false (or perhaps turn them into byte values first?)
for assignment in self.module.all_nodes():
@ -273,33 +280,6 @@ class Optimizer:
a.parent = old_stmt.parent
return a
def combine_assignments_into_multi(self) -> None:
# fold multiple consecutive assignments with the same rvalue into one multi-assignment
for scope in self.module.all_nodes(Scope):
rvalue = None
assignments = [] # type: List[Assignment]
for stmt in list(scope.nodes):
if isinstance(stmt, Assignment):
if assignments:
if stmt.right == rvalue:
assignments.append(stmt)
continue
elif len(assignments) > 1:
# replace the first assignment by a multi-assign with all the others
for assignment in assignments[1:]:
print("{}: joined with previous assignment".format(assignment.sourceref))
assignments[0].left.nodes.extend(assignment.left.nodes)
scope.remove_node(assignment)
self.optimizations_performed = True
rvalue = None
assignments.clear()
else:
rvalue = stmt.right
assignments.append(stmt)
else:
rvalue = None
assignments.clear()
@no_type_check
def remove_unused_subroutines(self) -> None:
# some symbols are used by the emitted assembly code from the code generator,

View File

@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ __all__ = ["ProgramFormat", "ZpOptions", "math_functions", "builtin_functions",
"UndefinedSymbolError", "AstNode", "Directive", "Scope", "Block", "Module", "Label", "Expression",
"Register", "Subroutine", "LiteralValue", "AddressOf", "SymbolName", "Dereference", "IncrDecr",
"ExpressionWithOperator", "Goto", "SubCall", "VarDef", "Return", "Assignment", "AugAssignment",
"InlineAssembly", "BuiltinFunction", "TokenFilter", "parser", "connect_parents",
"InlineAssembly", "BuiltinFunction", "TokenFilter", "parser", "connect_parents", "DatatypeNode",
"parse_file", "coerce_constant_value", "datatype_of", "check_symbol_definition", "NotCompiletimeConstantError"]
@ -546,7 +546,8 @@ class Dereference(Expression):
@attr.s(cmp=False)
class IncrDecr(AstNode):
# increment or decrement something by a CONSTANT value (1 or more)
# increment or decrement something by a small CONSTANT value (1..255)
# larger values will be treated/converted as an augmented assignment += or -=.
# one subnode: target (Register, SymbolName, or Dereference).
operator = attr.ib(type=str, validator=attr.validators.in_(["++", "--"]))
howmuch = attr.ib(default=1)
@ -567,7 +568,7 @@ class IncrDecr(AstNode):
self.nodes.append(target)
def __attrs_post_init__(self):
# make sure the amount is always >= 0
# make sure the amount is always >= 0, flip the operator if needed
if self.howmuch < 0:
self.howmuch = -self.howmuch
self.operator = "++" if self.operator == "--" else "--"

View File

@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
import pytest
from il65.datatypes import DataType, VarType, STRING_DATATYPES, FLOAT_MAX_POSITIVE, FLOAT_MAX_NEGATIVE, char_to_bytevalue
from il65.plyparse import coerce_constant_value, LiteralValue, Scope, AddressOf, SymbolName, VarDef
from il65.datatypes import DataType, STRING_DATATYPES, FLOAT_MAX_POSITIVE, FLOAT_MAX_NEGATIVE, char_to_bytevalue
from il65.plyparse import coerce_constant_value, LiteralValue, Scope, SymbolName, VarDef
from il65.compile import ParseError
from il65.plylex import SourceRef
from il65.emit import to_hex, to_mflpt5

92
tests/test_optimizer.py Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,92 @@
import pytest
from il65.plyparse import IncrDecr, AugAssignment, VarDef, SymbolName
from il65.optimize import optimize
from .test_parser import parse_source
def test_incrdecr_joins_nonfloat():
src = """~ test {
X ++
X ++
X += 10
Y--
Y--
Y-=20
}"""
result = parse_source(src)
testscope = result.scope.nodes[0].nodes[0]
assert len(testscope.nodes) == 6
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[0], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[0].howmuch == 1
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[1], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[1].howmuch == 1
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[2], AugAssignment)
assert testscope.nodes[2].right.value == 10
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[3], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[3].howmuch == 1
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[4], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[4].howmuch == 1
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[5], AugAssignment)
assert testscope.nodes[5].right.value == 20
# now optimize the incrdecrs (joins them)
optimize(result)
testscope = result.scope.nodes[0].nodes[0]
assert len(testscope.nodes) == 2 # @todo broken optimization right now
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[0], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[0].operator == "++"
assert testscope.nodes[0].howmuch == 12
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[1], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[1].operator == "--"
assert testscope.nodes[1].howmuch == 22
def test_incrdecr_joins_float():
src = """~ test {
var .float flt = 0
flt ++
flt ++
flt += 10
flt --
flt --
flt --
flt -= 5
}"""
result = parse_source(src)
testscope = result.scope.nodes[0].nodes[0]
assert len(testscope.nodes) == 8
# now optimize the incrdecrs (joins them)
optimize(result)
testscope = result.scope.nodes[0].nodes[0]
assert len(testscope.nodes) == 2
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[0], VarDef)
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[1], IncrDecr)
assert testscope.nodes[1].operator == "++"
assert testscope.nodes[1].howmuch == 4
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[1].target, SymbolName)
assert testscope.nodes[1].target.name == "flt"
def test_large_incrdecr_to_augassign():
src = """~ test {
X ++
X ++
X += 255
Y --
Y --
Y -= 255
}"""
result = parse_source(src)
testscope = result.scope.nodes[0].nodes[0]
assert len(testscope.nodes) == 6
# now optimize; joins the incrdecrs then converts to augassign because values are too large.
optimize(result)
testscope = result.scope.nodes[0].nodes[0]
assert len(testscope.nodes) == 2
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[0], AugAssignment)
assert testscope.nodes[0].left.name == "X"
assert testscope.nodes[0].operator == "+="
assert testscope.nodes[0].right.value == 257
assert isinstance(testscope.nodes[1], AugAssignment)
assert testscope.nodes[1].left.name == "Y"
assert testscope.nodes[1].operator == "-="
assert testscope.nodes[1].right.value == 257

View File

@ -165,8 +165,7 @@ def test_block_nodes():
def test_parser_2():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
999(1,2)
[zz]()
}
@ -186,8 +185,7 @@ def test_parser_2():
def test_typespec():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
[$c000.word] = 5
[$c000 .byte] = 5
[AX .word] = 5
@ -232,8 +230,7 @@ def test_typespec():
def test_char_string():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
var x1 = '@'
var x2 = 'π'
var x3 = 'abc'
@ -255,8 +252,7 @@ def test_char_string():
def test_boolean_int():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
var x1 = true
var x2 = false
A = true
@ -272,7 +268,7 @@ def test_boolean_int():
assert type(assgn2.right.value) is int and assgn2.right.value == 0
def test_incrdecr():
def test_incrdecr_operators():
sref = SourceRef("test", 1, 1)
with pytest.raises(ValueError):
IncrDecr(operator="??", sourceref=sref)
@ -350,8 +346,7 @@ def test_symbol_lookup():
def test_const_numeric_expressions():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
A = 1+2+3+4+5
X = 1+2*5+2
Y = (1+2)*(5+2)
@ -391,8 +386,7 @@ def test_const_numeric_expressions():
def test_const_logic_expressions():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
A = true or false
X = true and false
Y = true xor false
@ -420,8 +414,7 @@ def test_const_logic_expressions():
def test_const_other_expressions():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
memory memvar = $c123
A = &memvar ; constant
X = &sin ; non-constant
@ -444,8 +437,7 @@ def test_const_other_expressions():
def test_vdef_const_folds():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
const cb1 = 123
const cb2 = cb1
const cb3 = cb1*3
@ -490,8 +482,7 @@ def test_vdef_const_folds():
def test_vdef_const_expressions():
src = """
~ {
src = """~ test {
var bvar = 99
var .float fvar = sin(1.2-0.3)
var .float flt2 = -9.87e-6

View File

@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
import pytest
from il65.datatypes import DataType
from il65.plyparse import LiteralValue, VarDef, VarType, DatatypeNode, ExpressionWithOperator, Scope, AddressOf, SymbolName, UndefinedSymbolError
from il65.datatypes import DataType, VarType
from il65.plyparse import (LiteralValue, VarDef, DatatypeNode, ExpressionWithOperator,
Scope, AddressOf, SymbolName, UndefinedSymbolError)
from il65.plylex import SourceRef